Interviewing and Hiring Guidelines
Overview
The interview process remains a critical step in hiring, but today, it’s about more than just skills and qualifications. Employers must focus on identifying candidates who align with their organization’s culture, values, and goals. Hiring the wrong person can be costly—not only financially but also in terms of productivity, morale, and team dynamics.
Modern hiring practices prioritize a structured and inclusive approach to interviewing, ensuring all candidates are evaluated fairly and equitably. Employers must also remain informed about legal and human rights requirements to avoid risks, such as discrimination claims. In Canada, for example, employers must comply with provincial employment standards and the Human Rights Code, while those in the U.S. must be aware of federal and state laws governing employment practices.
Recommendations for Hiring Practices
( These are general recommendations for guidance only. Please consult your local provincial or state laws)
1. Preparing a Job Description
Example: Job descriptions that indicate a preference for a nurse with Canadian experience may limit applications from new Canadians, and could be perceived as discrimination based on race, place of origin or ethnic origin.
2. Posting the job
3. Job Qualifications
Avoid listing preferences such as “mature candiates only” as this can be perceived as discrimination based on age.
4. Resume / Candidate Screening
5. Interviewing
Prepare in advance a list of interview questions that are based on the requirements of the job. It is helpful to ask all candiate the same set of questions to ensure consistency. Be aware that Employers have an obligation to accomodate candidates during the interview or testing process. If an applicant discloses a disability to you in the interview process avoid questions relating to the disability or to the diagnosis. The employer does have the right to make inquiries about the accomodation needs but not to the disability itself. Interview questions should be limited to the candiates ability to perform the essential duties of the job. Prepare standardized interview questions to assess each candidate fairly and consistently. Avoid unstructured interviews, as they may lead to biases and inconsistencies.
5. Selecting Your Candidate
Guide to Human Rights Hiring
Modern workplaces must reflect inclusivity and equity. Employers must avoid questions or comments that directly or indirectly violate the Human Rights Code or employment law. The following list is an example of inappropriate questions or remarks based on prohibited grounds of the Human Rights Code.
1. Race / colour / ancestry / place of origin / ethnic origin / citizenship
Questions about mother tongue.
Questions about or relating to birth-place, nationality of ancestors, spouse and other relatives or Canadian citizenship.
Offensive remarks of a racist nature and remarks about the race, ancestry or parents’ origin.
What country do you come from?
What is your nationality?
Where are your parents/grandparents from?
Why don’t you have an accent?
2. Creed/ Religion
Questions about creed or religion, unless they are asked by a special interest organization such as a church.
What is your religion?
Are you of religion x? I’m not.
Would you have concerns working with people not of religion x?
What religious holidays do you observe?
3. Sex
Note: Questions about gender if gender is a reasonable and genuine requirement for a particular job, such as employment in a shelter for women escaping violence, may be appropriate. Other questions concerning the applicant’s sex, including questions about pregnancy or child-bearing plans, are inappropriate.Do you plan to have children?
When do you plan to have children and how many?
Are you pregnant?
Will you be taking maternity leave in the next 5 years?
4. Sexual Orientation
What is your sexual orientation?
5. Gender Identity or Gender Expression
6. Record of Offences
7. Disability
How come you are using a wheelchair?
Have you been blind all your life?
What is your medical condition?
8. Age
Won’t you be retiring soon?
You dont seem old enough to be a manager?
9. Marital Status
Are you single or married?
How will you balance having kids, a husband and a job?
10. Family Status
Are you married?
Do you have children?